So, what are we? Why nobody will define the relationship

Three months in. You know how they take their tea. You've met the flatmate, a small pile of their hoodies is building up at yours, and you've typed "so what are we?" into the chat at least four times. You have never once sent it.

That is the situationship, and it is quietly miserable in a way that is hard to explain to your mates. You're not single, so you can't properly look. You're not together, so you can't properly relax. You're just "seeing someone", said with a small wince, while you both wait for the other person to be brave first.

What is a situationship, actually?

More than a hookup, less than a relationship, and nobody has said anything out loud. The habits of a couple (good morning texts, weekend plans, meeting friends) with none of the agreements. The word really took off in 2022, when Tinder's Year in Swipe reported a 49% rise in members putting "situationship" in their bios, and framed it as a middle ground people were choosing rather than settling for. That's Tinder's own data, and four years old now, so add a pinch of salt, but the word stuck because the thing is everywhere.

And a lot of these grey areas start on an app. YouGov's big survey on relationships this summer found dating apps account for one in nine relationships in Britain, and around one in five among people in their thirties.

Why won't they define the relationship?

Rarely because they're a villain. Mostly because nobody wants to go first, and asking feels like it might end the whole thing. A 2026 study of young adults' situationships in the journal Societies (a small one, 14 people in Australia, but vivid) heard this again and again. The rules around exclusivity were unclear, and, as one participant put it, "nobody talks about them directly".

The apps don't help. The researchers described a "perpetual alternatives" mindset, where someone better always feels one more swipe away, so committing to the person in front of you feels like closing a tab you might want later.

And texting is the perfect hiding place. Participants said messaging made it easier to dodge serious conversations and keep things surface level. You can leave a "what are we" on read. It is much harder to leave it hanging in the air on a call.

Why does a situationship hurt so much?

Because ambiguity is its own kind of pain. The people in that Societies study described anxiety, knocked self-esteem and constantly watching for signs they were about to be replaced. And when it ended, their hurt got waved away, by other people and sometimes by themselves, because it "wasn't a real relationship".

Stylist's piece on why situationships are so hard to get over led with a line that says it all: "I never knew where we stood". When it ends, there's no clean thing to grieve.

It also clashes with the timetable most of us privately carry. When YouGov asked Britons how long you should wait to say "I love you", the most common answer was three months (24%), with six months next (19%). Three months was the top answer for meeting the family, too. A situationship sails past those markers in total silence, and you feel every missed one.

Why do people stay in situationships?

Because it works just well enough. A 2025 study in Sexuality & Culture looked at over a hundred situationship experiences, reported by college students, alongside in-depth interviews. People felt more satisfied and committed when their emotional needs were being met and when the other person made them feel prioritised, and talking about the future, even vaguely, seemed to ease the worry. Even a woolly "we should go away somewhere" takes the edge off for a bit. The lead researcher, Mickey Langlais, called the whole state "sort of like relationship purgatory": enough warmth to keep you there, never enough to settle you.

That's the trap. The nice bits are real. That's why you stay. It's also why three months becomes eight.

What actually helps, whatever app you're on

Give it a deadline. Not for them, for you. If you're still guessing at three months, that's your cue to ask, not to buy more guessing time.

Ask out loud. On a call or in person, not by text. The question dies in drafts, and a typed "what are we lol" is too easy to swerve. Voices make vagueness awkward, which is the point, and it's the same reason it's worth calling before a first date.

Say what you want first. Something like "I'd like this to be exclusive, how do you feel?" beats auditing them for clues. You're allowed to want a relationship. Wanting one was never the embarrassing part.

Believe the answer. "I don't really do labels" is a complete answer. So is a joke, a subject change, or "why do we need to ruin it?". Vague back means no.

Rate consistency over intensity. Hinge's 2026 report on LGBTQIA+ daters found 86% said consistent communication from someone they're dating makes them feel less anxious, and summed it up as consistency feeling more romantic than the spark. It's the app's own survey, and about LGBTQIA+ daters specifically, but it matches what the academics found: the cure for ambiguity is someone who shows up the same way twice.

Dating in London

London is the natural habitat of the situationship. Over nine million people, everyone busy, everyone secretly convinced someone marginally better is at a different pub. "We should sort something" can roll on for three weeks without anyone technically lying, and plenty of almost-relationships have quietly died of the distance between Walthamstow and Tooting.

Then add November, deep into cuffing season, when suddenly everyone wants someone to watch telly with until March, and you get peak grey area: maximum cosiness, minimum clarity. If you're going to ask the question, ask it before you've bought them a Christmas present.

A dating app built for talking

Situationships live in the chat. The dodge, the drafts, the three-day silences: all of it needs endless texting to survive.

CheckIn is a new dating app built around voice notes, GIFs and video calls, with no back-and-forth texting. You each get one short text per match, just the once (and another after a CheckIn call of ten minutes or more), and everything else is said out loud. So the "so what is this?" conversation happens the way it should: with a tone of voice, where vague answers sound as vague as they are. With barely anything to type, there's not much for a chatbot to write for anyone either.

A CheckIn is a video call, with a quick selfie check before your first one. You can have five matches at a time, so nobody is keeping you warm as option number nine. It's live in the UK now, and you can download it on the App Store.

It's very hard to stay a "what are we" with someone you actually talk to.

FAQs

What is a situationship? A connection with the habits of a relationship and none of the agreements. Usually one person is quietly hoping for more.

When should you ask "what are we"? When not knowing starts costing you sleep. There's no rule, but three months is the most common answer Britons gave YouGov for when to say "I love you" and when to meet the family, so asking where you stand by then is hardly rushing it.

How do you end a situationship? The same way you'd end a relationship: kindly, clearly and out loud. You both deserve a proper conversation, label or no label, and disappearing on someone you've spent months with hurts more than you'd think.

Sources

  • "The YouGov Big Survey on Relationships", YouGov, August 2026. yougov.com

  • "Section 3: Relationship attitudes and ideals", The YouGov Big Survey on Relationships, YouGov, August 2026. yougov.com

  • Anderson and Phillips, "All the Feels, None of the Labels: Young Adults' Experiences of Situationships", Societies, 2026. doi.org/10.3390/soc16020042

  • Eric W. Dolan, "New psychology research reveals why people stay in situationships", PsyPost, 2025 (on Langlais, Guzman, Toohey, Podberesky and Lee, "Are Situationships situational?: A Mixed-Methods Study on the Motivations for Being in a Situationship", Sexuality & Culture, 2025, doi.org/10.1007/s12119-025-10402-8). psypost.org

  • Jemma Sbeg, "'I never knew where we stood': why it's so hard to get over a situationship", Stylist, 2025 (subscribers only). stylist.co.uk

  • Kirk Miller, "The Biggest Trend for Tinder Users in 2022 Is the 'Situationship'", InsideHook, 2022 (on Tinder's Year in Swipe 2022). insidehook.com

  • "New Hinge Report Finds LGBTQIA+ Daters Are Prioritizing Clarity Over Ambiguity" (the 2026 LGBTQIA+ D.A.T.E. Report), Hinge, 2026. hinge.co

  • "London's population", Trust for London, 2026 (ONS population estimates via Nomis). trustforlondon.org.uk

Next
Next

Green flags you’ll never spot in a text